Monday, August 9, 2010

Music Mondays- Mixed Feelings




While I typically am not a fan of the content of his lyrics, I don't think it can be denied that Eminem is extremely talented. His most recently album even seems a bit more mature (so far). I like his most recent single, Love the Way you Lie. I feel that is breaks down the thought process of many couples who are stuck in abusive relationships, and I respect that. However, I am disappointed when I think of how many people do not see that this is a message about how damaging they are. Eminem and Rihanna are not naive... they know more people will buy the record because of the "sick hook" and are aware of how many people will use this song to identify with the reality of abusive relationships in unhealthy ways. So are they really teaching people about the dangers of abusive relationships, or are they irresponsible in their handling of this song and glorifying the subject? I understand that Rihanna wants to send a message about Domestic Violence, but her lyrics/the TITLE of the song are the only words many people pay attention to, and are the most misleading... I like the way it hurts, I love the way you lie... This is what I take issue with. While I agree Eminem "cleverly breaks down the cycle of violence "(rihanna), it is the hook and the beat that set the tone for listeners. They will hear Eminem say "Don't you hear sincerity in my voice when I talk", but not catch that he intentionally raises his voice to a disgruntled yell as he says it. Somehow the admittance to lying in his apologies is taken as something he does out of a twisted love, rather than the character simply being twisted and disturbed.

Overall I think this is a great song. Do I think Eminem was being apologetic and thoughtful in writing it? Sure. Do I think he intended to write in a way that would provide instant buzz, and was aware of the ramifications of this song in the hands of his more ignorant fans? Of course. I love it for the music and the conversation it can bring about. I hope that enough women who need to be free of Domestic Violence will have someone who can use this as a tool to speak some wisdom & compassion into their lives.

On another note... I don't like seeing my hobbit in the role of abusive bf. Also, I judge myself just a little for thinking he still looks hot. ;) Drop the booze and pick up a jar of peanut butter Charlie!!!

2 comments:

Jill said...

Bri... cleverly written! I completely agree with you on all sides! I couldn't take my eyes off the video and actually ended up giving my students an extra 3 minutes of break time so I could finish it! haha

Corrigan Vaughan said...

I would add that I don't think the message of the video is clear. Their abusive relationship is almost romanticized, and Rihanna's hook seems to validate it. Since both characters are abusive, it's hard to empathize with either one. It comes across as dysfunction more than flat-out domestic violence. The scenes of violence are also juxtaposed against scenes of what looks to be incredibly fulfilling, spontaneous sex. So, what is the viewer to deduce if not that going through the pain is worth it for intense intimacy? In the end, the couple is seen kissing. Nobody has grown or changed, and there have been no consequences. The house burns down, but our seeing Dominic & Megan afterward insinuates that either they were not inside, that the burning house was not literal but a metaphor, or that they got to be together forever in the afterlife, like some sort of Romeo & Juliet.